Too many inconsistencies and inaccuracies:
Naudin has a different single wire assembly instead of telephone wire wound against twisted double wire without indicating the output connections of these 4 ends, which can change everything (assembly used for 70 years in HF and VHF for broadband transformers, even in our cell phones !!
False phrade
The resistance of the wires increases with frequency; this effect decreases with the diameter of the wires: smaller wires, less resistance due to the skin effect.
because without care by mixing resistance and surface impedance, without explaining the need to multiply the number of fine Litz wires, etc ... because the resistance of a single wire increases by decreasing its diameter at any fixed frequency !!
Finally :
When Swiss sponsors contacted Richard VIALLE, he had this self-generating device. He was invited to come to Switzerland with his self-generating bar and his function generator to power it. They organized a measurement of the input power and the output power by a person working at the Ecole Polytechnique de Lausanne in Switzerland, in the section of physical measurements.
There, a physicist, specialist in sound and waves used a powerful oscilloscope and a metal resistance of 1 ohm to measure the voltage across the input winding of the auto generator and across the resistance that had been put in series . With the resistance in series he determined the current, and he measured the cosine of the phase shift angle. An internal calculation function of the oscilloscope gave power with this data.
During this time the autogenerator delivered at output 0,16 Watts on a 4V and 40mA bulb. The measurement performed gave an input consumption of 0,000001 Watt = 10-6 Watt, that is: COP = 160.
Then the mass of the generator was disconnected from the half-bar, which means that the half-bar remained supplied by the only "hot spot" leaving the function generator. So we had as a loss only the antenna effect, radiation, even more the effect of resistive skin. So even less as a starter. The bulb lit a little more dimly, but remained clearly lit.
The person doing the measurement exclaimed "there is nothing at the entrance"
The power consumed at the input was considered to be zero, below the device's measurement threshold. Virtually we could then have given COP = infinite, but obviously that would be false because there are losses by radiation, even if they are minimal. In any case, the COP was therefore even larger than before. And this demonstrates in passing that, as indicated, the antenna produced by the coil is totally unsuitable for radiating a significant fraction of the input power; because it is not made for that.
This measurement was made with the function generator of Richard VIALLE limited in frequency between 25Mhz and 27MHz.
is full of errors in coarse measurements, because around 25MHz, short waves, the smallest piece of wire makes a beautiful antenna which gives a nice power very easily underestimated, as you can see with a piece of wire and a little bit of impedance matching, as a TV antenna.
The HF power measurement must be very serious, because very easy to crash, and to announce astronomical COPs, which
if very real can quickly be proven by heating your house or a small calorimeter, model of a house, with a 3MHz self-oscillating generator with a single transistor (efficiency 50% to 80%), powered by charged supercapacitor (low capacity of a few seconds) , which with a crazy COP of 100 to 160000, should never discharge and heat in perpetuity !!
This type of crazy COP measurement is the only one without errors !!
And we must be able to heat our buttocks in perpetuity without an energy source, with a COP = 160000 as astronomical !!
Naudin has never done this type of calorimetric manipulation in more than 10 years .
Rossi claims to do it, but secretly, not very verifiable and he was not using it at home, to heat himself last winter with KW !!!
What is told is incoherent, even delusional, in total contradiction with what makes all our electronic devices, telephones and TV work, sold in billions of copies, for example !!
When we see VIALLE unable to make an auto-oscillator (a few €, a transistor, coil and some capacitors and a diode, the kind that I have made by the dozen formerly for other purposes) to have the right frequency, with its sales pitch inconsistent, we have no confidence !!!
Raz the bowl of waking dreams.
In response to janic, this is an example of how we separate the true from the false, by the experience and the consistency of these experiences.
And if you continue to think that it is proven, you can send me this functional assembly with auto oscillator of a few tens of € (considering the price of copper), to heat my buttocks in perpetuity without energy source, with a COP = 160000 as astronomical !!
I will pay you 1000 € and therefore a financial COP of more than 10, if my buttocks are very hot !!
