pb2488 wrote:elephant wrote:2) if some great homeopathic classics work very well on standard pathologies (Nux Vomica, Arnica, Echnicea, calendulla) others require a frank habit on the part of the practitioner and one has the impression that they do not work on everything the world. This is also why homeopathy must be practiced by a doctor, because you have to know its limits and be able to say at certain times: "stop, there is an emergency, we use the good old methods"
For standard pathologies, "nothing" also works very well.
But fortunately it does not replace conventional drugs when they are needed, it would be dangerous ...elephant wrote:3) anything (such as the use of a mint toothpaste or the use of certain spices) can prevent homeopathy from working
lol ... as if by chance ...
What was unfortunate in this debate was that what you said furiously suggested that you were very biased.
There is necessarily a hierarchy of care VS ailments. Just as there is a hierarchy to be respected in individual prevention measures which => influence the field => influence the patient's response => influence the results of ethiology ... and so on.
So no, it's no coincidence that in hot countries we eat spicy food ...
pb2488 wrote:elephant wrote:But when we see the spectacular effectiveness of certain preparations on young children, we are still allowed to ask questions.
What is spectacular is the ability of the human body to heal itself.
...so what?
pb2488 wrote:elephant wrote:And the problem is: when you see a kid coming in your office with a beautiful angina, you can not afford to give him a placebo.
Why not. Anyway, if angina is viral, as is very often the case, there is not much to do .... we must wait until it happens ... just a little spray to relieve at the limit.
Cdlt
Not much to do? If, if, on the contrary there are many things to do, it is a good indicator of the partial collapse of the immune system and indicative of the deficiencies of an organism. It is a state which proves an inability to resist and combats certain viruses (benign? It depends for whom ...).
We can offer a general assessment, if the patient wishes, to start ...
elephant wrote:Good pb2488 is always right, in future I will not participate any more forum where he intervenes. maybe when he has my age and my experience, we can talk with him.
Exactly, but I would say that he is rarely right, and when he is, he doesn't know it because his lack of knowledge means that he mixes a lot of things. So ditto I will no longer participate in his posts, at least as long as ....