izentrop wrote:The curve on the analysis of cesium 237 in wines posted by Exnihiloest challenged me
Of great importance, cesium 137 (and not 237). Then if you did not immediately realize that it was phony is that you really have no field competence in this area! 15in collaboration with the WHO have at least allowed me not to do this type of blunder!
All this for, as usual, trying to justify a pseudo non-partisan attitude. While the bottom does not mean anything.
I knew it would be necessary to repeat that (in particular):
- cesium cannot disappear from the body as if by magic, it can only be added to it ... (if we want to speak "seriously")
- These curves are totally bogus.
- if we want to talk "seriously" we must also talk about the MOST IMPORTANT, which is low dose irradiation, in statistics with a "low" evaluation probably> 2mios of deaths over 70 years,> 90mios tell us some experts. UNSCEAR figures, like what we can say anything by taking only partial stats (with Fukushima we have not finished counting the dead.)
- if we want to talk "seriously" we must also talk about the MOST IMPORTANT, it is the catastrophe of the pitiful output of nuclear power <1.
- if we want to talk "seriously" we must also talk about the MOST IMPORTANT, that is to say why our economy has created from scratch the "need for nuclear power" to satisfy the industry which is a bottomless pit of wasting resources mining.
I also come from an industrial background but I will not compromise myself in demonstrations that do not hold water. In short, have fun "playing scientist" when you don't have the skills. By making diagrams say what we want them to say, we can make the figures say anything (well, the figures from COGEMA, and others, it's a bit like asking the American administration to to estimate the number of victims of the wars of the gulf, or to the former Nazis the estimate of the deaths in the concentration camps, it is of a credible ...). But it's good for self-esteem, if that's reassuring ....
Bof, make the buzz to defend the indefensible with fake statistics, good for the trash! What interest.