@sicetaitsimple »09 / 05 / 19, 21: 22
janic wrote: to choose between the testimonies of the victims and the nonsense peddled by the obscurantists of the nuclear, I opt without hesitation for the victims, of course!
I have no ability to judge the effects of Chernobyl more than 30 years later, it is certainly the major nuclear accident occurred in the world and it inevitably had consequences
Unfortunately these 30 years have erased from the map of the world, the victims in question among the liquidators, only having lived this hell and are no longer there to testify. It's a bit like the shoah that dates back to 80 years ago and that some deny having existed or at least as some describe it. However, it remains all the same those who lived it
inside (those who survived) who can testify (since most of the evidence was suppressed by the Nazis)
On the other hand, when you tell us I am summarizing what I understood "I read a book called" the crime of Chernobyl "and basically even if I simplify" the whole truth is there ", you take yourself a little the feet in the carpet compared to your usual speech on "inform yourself", "study" ....
Oh, there, no! I do not have anything at all, and there is no truth here or there, but of testimonys on the spot, people concerned by this catastrophe namely the liquidators and the populations close to this explosion. Even if I lived closely the history of the radioactive cloud stopped at the borders by our customs officers. However, apart from a few rare documentaries using cinematographic archives and direct testimony, the only discourse that remains with the public, it remains the "recognized" organizations that are embarrassed by these testimonies in question.
It's just a book, I'm not questioning the intellectual honesty of its authors, but it's a point in the cloud of points.
This is not a station novel, but a summary of what people have lived in their flesh, not hidden behind organizations that have not set foot directly there, by scientists who have, at the cost of their own life, their health and their social and professional position, lived among these victims, not behind an office thousands of KM away. in the same way, moreover, that there remains only books of testimonys of this shoah: what credit then can you bring them if you did not live it personally?
So, without getting caught up in the emotion, read this book of 700 pages, and of course find out, study the subject, compare the information and then give your opinion.
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré