by Did67 » 24/02/20, 19:39
So far, the virus has grown in production greenhouses. In these places, seeds are never produced.
The production of commercial seeds follows a completely different route. And the professionals have separate circuits: who knows "De Ruiter" or "Voltz", etc ... Even if some brands play on both counts: professionals and individuals ...
Alas, we cannot totally exclude that at the start, it comes from the same multipliers (even if commercial greenhouses - even organic - essentially use the latest hybrids arrived on the market; generally not available for individuals). There are therefore again different pathways.
The risk seems extremely low to me. At least for now. If it becomes widespread, it will be another story.
Here is what we can read on the site of "the good seed":
"Many of you are worried about this new virus on tomatoes, ToBRFV, which would decimate farms in the Middle East and which would be preparing to invade Europe, France, the world of course!
Faced with the media frenzy and the numerous questions that this poses, it seemed important to us to answer you a few points.
Is this virus dangerous?
For humans, no. The virus makes the tomato non-marketable because it distorts the fruit and prevents it from ripening, but it has no impact on humans.
It is dangerous economically for large greenhouse operations whose production could be devastated very quickly.
As an individual, am I concerned?
Not really, even if that doesn't prevent vigilance.
In France, there is only one farm in Finistère to be affected to date. The risk of spread is minimal for amateurs who only cultivate a few plants scattered in their garden. If this should be the case, although it can be annoying for your home, all you have to do is burn the plants, disinfect the soil and carry out crop rotations.
You are much more likely to catch mildew on your tomatoes!
Is there a risk with seeds from La Bonne Graine?
The virus could be carried by seeds (but not only!) And that is why you are legitimately worried.
Regarding our seeds, please know that we are subject to strict regulations that we scrupulously respect and our seeds have a European phytosanitary passport. All of our products are controlled by the competent authorities (SOC, GNIS) and our seeds, although intended for the amateur market, all come from the professional sector, which ensures us traceability, they are not the fruit of a small production "at the bottom of the garden" such as you might find on certain Internet sites.
We mainly produce in France, not in Israel or the Middle East (home of the infestation) and, although we cannot 100% guarantee the absence of risks, our seeds are safe.
The risks of viruses have always existed and panic or catastrophism have never been the adequate response. Like the flu, setting up preventive actions is the best solution to minimize the risks: buy your seeds from recognized players (of which we are part), set up crop rotations, have good cultural practices by promoting the life of the soil against chemical fertilizers and you will be putting the odds in your favor. "
It is rather honest, even if the "mainly" in France, poiur their place of production, is vague ... Likewise the argument of "strict compliance with regulations". No one will doubt that the seeds and plants used by the infested producer (a member of the Savéol cooperative) did just as much - respect the standards and regulations! A priori, it came from the Netherlands via England. As probably many plants that we buy in garden centers ... So yes, producing plants considerably reduces the risk. From its seeds even more ... On the other hand, the exchange of seeds without control, without respect for standards, could become risky, as well as "plant fairs" (not for the moment, but it could become foci of dissemination if the virus leaves the current highly controlled framework).
1 x