eclectron wrote:ABC2019 wrote:eclectron wrote:You could give us a less moldy speech.
We really wonder why you hang out here and that you are not Minister of Science?
if you don't mind contradicting the second principle
which report ???
First of all, it is for a very specific device on which we have no absolute certainties. I do not question the second principle in absolute terms.
a principle applies to everything, there is no exception, and if there is only one, it is necessary to abandon the principle: for example the only "particular device" of the Michelson interferometer which showed the invariance of the speed of light in ONE experiment was enough to destroy all Newtonian mechanics and have to replace it with the theory of relativity. And a single experiment contrary to relativity would be enough to bring it down in its turn, even if one has not yet observed any.
The connection is that you make judgments on what I say about scientific work, while you show yourself that you have only a very rough idea of what scientific rigor is.
ABC2019 wrote: but that you trust uncertain measurements
Why don't you tell the climatologists, who according to you obviously are all idiots. Each post is the same blah
As for Thibado and his team, physicists who work and do not know the second principle?
If I follow you, only you know better than everyone else, better all those who work and all screw up. So I reiterate, why are you bothering here to delude yourself and why not apply to be Minister of Science?
well yes, I say that there are bad scientists and good scientists, and when I find that there are bad scientists, I say it, and I say why. Yes Thibado is for me a bad physicist, and this is confirmed by the fact that he could not answer anything when I showed him that his project would amount to violating the second principle, a good physicist would certainly have answered me. explaining why I was wrong if that had been the case.
I am not saying that it is "everyone" who is wrong, and I do not see why there would only be a "minister of science" to do good science!
To pass for an idiot in the eyes of a fool is a gourmet pleasure. (Georges COURTELINE)
Mééé denies nui went to parties with 200 people and was not even sick moiiiiiii (Guignol des bois)