At 50, Beznau, the oldest nuclear power plant in Europe, denies being obsolete
AFP • 05 / 12 / 2019
Reactor 1 at the Swiss nuclear power plant at Beznau, the oldest in service in Europe, celebrates its 50th birthday at the beginning of December, far too long for the ecological parties and associations which consider it dangerous and call for its immediate shutdown.
December 9, 1969: The Beatles are not yet separated, a man has just walked on the Moon and Switzerland launches, in the north of its territory, on an islet of the Aar river, the exploitation of its first nuclear power plant.
50 years later, on the bright blue wall of the reactor building 1 visible from the turbine room, we can read in German: "Anniversary 1969-2019. 355.000 hours of service".
And Beznau 1 is not far from being the nuclear dean of the world: according to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), only reactors 1 and 2 at Tarapur (west India) are ahead of it, after put into service in October 1969.
"It's a privilege to be able to work here," said Michael Dost, director of the plant managed by the Swiss electricity distributor Axpo, showing his pride in working in a monument of industrial history which, with its two reactors (the number 2 was commissioned in 1971) produces some 6.000 gigawatt / h, approximately twice the electricity consumption of Switzerland's largest city, Zurich (400.000 inhabitants).
While leading the visit for journalists on the site, especially in the heart of a control room with very "sixties" buttons and control panels, the boss of Beznau believes that the age of the plant is not a problem .
- 2CV and Tesla -
On the wall of the reactor building 1 of the Beznau power plant, we can read in German: "Anniversary 1969-2019. 355.000 hours of service", July 9, 2019 in Dottingen, Switzerland (AFP / Fabrice COFFRINI)
On the wall of the reactor building 1 of the Beznau power plant, we can read in German: "Anniversary 1969-2019. 355.000 hours of service", July 9, 2019 in Dottingen, Switzerland (AFP / Fabrice COFFRINI)
"A lot has been done on this installation", he explains to AFP, adding: "additions have been made (...), components have been modified, new equipment built and we are therefore in the process of high technical requirements that can be expected from a nuclear power plant ".
Asked by AFP, the Federal Inspectorate for Nuclear Safety (IFSN), the authority which oversees the safety of Swiss power plants, believes that "Beznau 1 has been able to prove that it fulfills the regulatory requirements thanks to major refitting ".
But for opponents of nuclear power, the work carried out does not compensate for the aging of the equipment.
"Large sums have been invested in this plant", admits for AFP Florian Kasser, nuclear referent at Greenpeace-Switzerland, "but you do not transform a 2CV into a Tesla, simply by investing in security measures".
The activist points, for example, to the latest three-year shutdown of the reactor - between 2015 and 2017 - linked in particular to analyzes on the pressurized water tank of the reactor, the steel of which had defects. Experts concluded that they were not caused by the operation of the reactor and did not present a danger, which the IFSN validated.
- Retirement at 61? -
But Greenpeace believes that the tests did not take into account the effects of radioactivity on the wear and tear of this tank. According to Mr. Kasser, Beznau therefore represents "a major risk in terms of nuclear safety".
A position also defended by the Greens who recorded a record progression in the last federal elections, at the end of October and demand the immediate closure of the plant.
The Beznau stop is not yet on the agenda, however.
Admittedly, the Swiss approved by referendum on May 21, 2017 a gradual exit from nuclear power - which represents about a third of the national electricity supply - by voting against the construction of new power plants.
But a few months earlier, on November 27, 2016, they had voted against an initiative to ban Swiss power plants from operating beyond 45 years of age.
Currently, Switzerland has four power stations: Gösgen, Leibstadt, Beznau and Mühleberg but the latter will definitively close on December 20.
"The lifespan of power plants is not defined," said the Energy Office.
"The effective operating period is therefore decided by safety, monitored by the IFSN and / or the operator (...) if it decides that the investment in additional safety measures is no longer economically viable ", he says.
Asked about this, the site owner said: "we plan to be able to operate the installation until 2030". It will then be time for Beznau 1 to retire. At 61 years old.
Long live Beznau.