Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India

How to stay healthy and prevent risks and consequences on your health and public health. occupational disease, industrial risks (asbestos, air pollution, electromagnetic waves ...), company risk (workplace stress, overuse of drugs ...) and individual (tobacco, alcohol ...).
Janic
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 19224
Registration: 29/10/10, 13:27
Location: bourgogne
x 3491

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Janic » 14/06/18, 09:49

(29'41 '')
In other words, if you ask yourself questions about matter, you are going to ask a physicist, if you ask yourself questions about the origin of mass, from which comes that elementary particles have acquired mass, you're going to ask a particle physicist, it's not your butcher's or someone else'sIn other words, we all collectively understand that science is the only approach that is the only one to answer scientific questions.
Superb reflection from E. Klein!
Indeed, he emphasizes that in science it is the "specialists" of a particular subject who are best able to answer the questions posed in their favorite area, not the local butcher.
In other words, when it comes to medical specialties, it is the A specialists who are most competent in their field, but not in another which is not within the competence of their competences, (nonexistent besides), as for the H or other medicines besides. CQFD!
0 x
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré
izentrop
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 13644
Registration: 17/03/14, 23:42
Location: picardie
x 1502
Contact :

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by izentrop » 14/06/18, 14:19

Undoubtedly, modern conventional medicine is based on science, while homeopathy is on esotericism.
0 x
Janic
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 19224
Registration: 29/10/10, 13:27
Location: bourgogne
x 3491

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Janic » 14/06/18, 16:59

Undoubtedly, modern conventional medicine is based on science, while homeopathy is on esotericism.
: Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: You don't have to, then know what science is, or esotericism!
Science is the body of knowledge and studies of universal value, characterized by an object and a method based on objective verifiable observations and rigorous reasoning.
However, their limits are blurred; in other words, there is no systematic categorization of the types of science, which also constitutes one of the questions of epistemology. Dominique Pestre thus explains that "what we put under the term" science "is by no means a circumscribed and stable object over time that we should simply describe" 11.
0 x
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré
Janic
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 19224
Registration: 29/10/10, 13:27
Location: bourgogne
x 3491

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Janic » 14/06/18, 18:39

FRONT ACUTE LOBAR PNEUMONIA
In a pregnant woman

My first homeopathy course had so baffled me that I almost went out before the end. The vicarious epistaxis of Bryonia had got the better of my Cartesian background, it was too much, completely ridiculous and unacceptable. I had taken half a page of handwritten notes on Bryonia: "inflammation of the serosa (pericardium, pleura, synovium), worsening at the slightest movement, need for fresh air, right laterality".

The next morning, I found myself in front of a patient suffering for three months from pericarditis and right pleural effusion, for which neither the cardiologist nor myself could do anything. "It's still unfortunate, I stay in bed without moving, it eventually improves, and as soon as I get up, at the slightest movement, it starts again!" I can't do anything anymore! ”

I said to myself: "it's weird, it vaguely reminds me of something ...". I found my handwritten half-page that I had not yet discarded, and since there was nothing else to do, I tried homeopathy. Dose or globule? High or low energy? I had no idea, and I randomly prescribed a dose of Bryonia 9CH. "I'll give it to you, well, we'll see what it does." »48 hours of precordial pain, generalized aches, then nothing, absolutely nothing, to the point that the cardiac ultrasound performed four days after the dose found nothing (two days before Bryonia, there was chest x-ray a consequent pericardial effusion and a right pleural effusion evaluated at 1,5 liters).

The patient was amazed, but not as much as his doctor. This quack thing seemed to be working for real! Conclusion (erroneous) of a beginner: "Bryonia is effective in pericarditis", so I had bought a dose in case… Which one was not made wait: 15 days later, in night guard, a magnificent pericarditis, with pain at the slightest movement, the feverish patient folded in two with both hands on the chest, "do not talk to me, do not move me ..." "Crr ... Crr ..." during auscultation, offset from PQ to ECG. I gave him a dose of Bryonia 15CH before hospitalizing him, specifying on my mail that he should be cured quickly. The intern in cardiology seems to have laughed a lot when reading my letter, and I received the following mail 15 days later: "when the symptoms disappeared within 48 hours, the diagnosis of pericarditis was rejected".

From there, I studied homeopathy thoroughly, and I enriched my emergency kit with a dozen remedies studied at the start of the first year.

And here we are in January, in the middle of an influenza epidemic. I am called for a pregnant woman of 6 months who has the flu, 40 °, and who can no longer move. I arrive at her house at three in the morning, she is a busy guard. "It's the flu, I had a big thrill of teeth chattering tonight, and the fever keeps going up" She coughs hoarse, it hurts so much that she has to hold the chest of both hands at each straight.

I examine it, it looks a little stunned with a temperature of 40 °, a rapid pulse, dry skin, no stiff neck, "sit down", (and immediately, it coughs hoarse), percussion of the chest, left lung: "pom, pom pom, pom", very hollow, right lung: "poc, poc, poc, poc", dull! A dullness like I had not heard since my internship! I put my two hands flat on his back. "Say 33! », And there, stupor, on the right side it vibrates under your fingers, frankly. I listen with my stethoscope: normal lung on the left, respiratory silence on the right with crackles on the periphery. I can't believe it: pneumonia like in the books, even during my internship, I had never seen such a characteristic. The only thing missing is the tubal breath and the rusty expectoration.

I explain to the patient that her condition is serious and that she must be hospitalized in an emergency.
She refuses, she doesn't want to leave home. I try to negotiate, I explain to him, nothing to do. I prepare to give her an injectable antibiotic, she refuses: "I can't take antibiotics, I'm pregnant". All my attempts to explain to her what she risks remain in vain, she is totally limited, hermetic to any explanation.

At that time, a two year old child begins to cry at the top of his lungs.
"And him, there, if at least he could leave me alone!" I can't take care of him, as soon as I move, I cough! "
And there, I think of Bryonia. I have some in my suitcase, homeopathy, she doesn't know but she wants to. I leave her the tube, I am exhausted and I leave saying that I will call her tomorrow morning.

I come home at five, fall asleep, and at seven sharp, I wake up with a start: "the pregnant woman!" I realize that I did not even make him sign a release, pneumonia in a pregnant woman treated by homeopathy, it will be untenable before the judges. I phone her, she is not worried, she feels better, she has only 38 °, she has less pain when she coughs ... I am not reassured and announces that I will spend the end of the day.

The same evening, I see her again on a visit: she no longer has a fever, she practically coughs no more, I examine her: left lung "pom, pom, pom, pom", right lung "pom, pom, pom, pom ”. I can not believe it! The vocal vibrations are normal and symmetrical, the auscultation is normal.

For the patient, it was only flu and she was right to stay at home. I reason aloud: "But then, it's homeopathy that ..." For the beginner homeopath that I am, the complete cure of a frank acute lobar pneumonia in 24 hours is simply inconceivable, impossible. At that time, I hear the voice of her husband, who had never yet appeared: "Me, anyway, I do not believe in homeopathy! "

From that day, a few years of failure or half-success awaited me before I managed to master the tool, but I had "proof" which had encouraged me to persevere.

http://ecole-homeopathie-auvergne-rhone ... -enceinte/
To be continued!
1 x
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré
pedrodelavega
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 3791
Registration: 09/03/13, 21:02
x 1311

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by pedrodelavega » 14/06/18, 20:15

Janic wrote:
Undoubtedly, modern conventional medicine is based on science, while homeopathy is on esotericism.
: Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: : Cheesy: You don't have to, then know what science is, or esotericism!
Science is the body of knowledge and studies of universal value, characterized by an object and a method based on objective verifiable observations and rigorous reasoning.
However, their limits are blurred; in other words, there is no systematic categorization of the types of science, which also constitutes one of the questions of epistemology. Dominique Pestre thus explains that "what we put under the term" science "is by no means a circumscribed and stable object over time that we should simply describe" 11.


"Science is the body of knowledge and studies of Universal, characterized by an object and a method based on observations verifiable objectives and rigorous reasoning. "

: Shock: .... The opposite of homeopathy ...
1 x
Janic
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 19224
Registration: 29/10/10, 13:27
Location: bourgogne
x 3491

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Janic » 14/06/18, 20:58

"Science is the body of knowledge and studies of universal value, characterized by an object and a method based on verifiable objective observations and rigorous reasoning."
The opposite of homeopathy ...
on the contrary! Each of the words, cited above, are applicable to H or other therapies. But, and that's what I spend my time repeating, is that each system, medical or not, has its own evaluation criteria. Let's take this sentence again:
SCIENCE : it is ONE knowledge for each object studied, whatever it is since it is not applicable to a particular object or subject.
ALL KNOWLEDGE :
all knowledge is automatically limited to current knowledge
STUDY OF UNIVERSAL VALUE:
Aviation knowledge has universal value for this specialty, but it cannot be applied to submarines, for example, which have their own value, limited to this specialty.
CHARACTERIZED BY AN OBJECT AND A METHOD BASED ON OBSERVATIONS:
all the methods, in each “trade” are characterized by an object, for example masonry or the cutting of diamonds or anything else.
BASED ON OBSERVATIONS :
obviously all that can be transformed into a method is the fact of observation.

Until then, each criterion is applicable to all subjects that can be examined
VERIFIABLE AND RIGOROUS REASONS.
This is the point that bothers each other. Some claiming that these criteria are also respected in H (as in A) and others claiming that they are not.
Who is right ?
Verifiable : Relating to anything or information that can be seen
The example (which will be followed by others) corresponds to it, all the H as the A note that their therapy works in the light of the results.
AND IS NOT SUBJECT TO A POSSIBLE CHALLENGE.
Here is the stumbling block in question: Any dispute is admissible only within the precise framework of a particular subject or object. An avionics engineer can challenge the work of another avionics engineer, therefore with equivalent skills, but his opinion and therefore his possible dispute, is and remains worthless vis-à-vis a marine engineer or a butcher to resume the example of Etienne Klein.
So the H corresponds well and in all respects to the above criteria.
It's up to you to prove the opposite!
0 x
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré
Gébé
Éconologue good!
Éconologue good!
posts: 361
Registration: 08/08/09, 20:02
x 65

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Gébé » 14/06/18, 21:47

https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hom%C3%A9opathie
Everything proves that it has no proper efficacy, that it is a pseudo science, that the followers are believers.
1 x
Janic
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 19224
Registration: 29/10/10, 13:27
Location: bourgogne
x 3491

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Janic » 15/06/18, 07:21

https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hom%C3%A9opathie
Everything proves that it has no proper efficacy, that it is a pseudo science, that the followers are believers.
everything proves that the methods used are not suitable for H measurements; because all are based on model A, which can only lead to failure exactly as the measurement methods of classical physics are unsuitable for measurements of quantum physics and yet both are physics just like medicine A and medicine H are medicines.
So the Wikipedia article which is only the expression of the choices of its authors, must be compared to the literature H and not to the unsuitable essays of the A. for, as if by chance, we do not find those of the H there, as another true example, experienced above and below.




A case of Infectious Mononucleosis
Dr Francois Gamby

Mylène, 19, is brought by her mother on a Sunday guard, for a fever that persists. She complains of leg pain, headache, diarrhea, hot head, and a painful ganglion in the neck. It is the fourth day that she is sick. She first had a headache, then the fever rose to 39 °. It is amorphous, does not move much. Her doctor, seen two days before, diagnosed pharyngitis and prescribed Advil + Doliprane. Mylène coughs a little, she has a little sore throat.

I will clarify the various complaints.

Fever is dominated by fatigue. The nights are bad: Mylène is soaked with sweat everywhere, especially the head, the hair. No particular smell.
Increased thirst, she drinks tea or water.

During the interview, I observe my patient. Mylène's eyes are half-closed, not fully open, half-closed, because of the headache, she tells me. She is very pale, and above all, she looks very tired, exhausted, without energy.

Something strikes me in his behavior, without knowing what exactly. Until I realize that she is frozen, not to say stuck in her chair, and that she answers very briefly: "no"; " Yes " ; " a little " ; " I dunno " ; "Blah". As if she had no desire, or no energy to respond. The tone is almost dry, without being brittle.

On examination: There is indeed pharyngitis, we cannot speak of true angina. Mylène insists on this very painful cervical ganglion. I request an EBV serology which will return positive, confirming the diagnosis of infectious mononucleosis.

Not knowing Mylène, I question her mom. Mylène is usually very dynamic, always thorough, full of enthusiasm. She loves dancing, fitness, going out with friends. She doesn't play sports because she doesn't like it.

"So why did you get sick?" You have an idea ? The exams (IUT management)? Did something happen? And there Mylène does not answer, but her eyes are veiled, she wipes a tear.

I hand him the pole: "a concern with a friend? She nodded and said very softly, "a girlfriend". "Are you sad?" " " Yes ". "I won't bother you anymore, that's enough for me to treat you".

Drug X given in 9 CH resulted in rapid local, general and mental healing.

A case of Infectious Mononucleosis - Mylène
After having specified the symptoms, carried out the examination and sought the elements to make a medical diagnosis (which will be confirmed to me by the result of the EBV serology), I research the homeopathic symptoms characteristic of the disease.
I use the Synthesis Directory which indicates, for each symptom, the list of possible homeopathic medicines.

The symptom which seemed to me at the same time the most original, singular, particular, and the surest, indisputable, I observed it during the consultation: the half-closed eyes.
• EYE, Open, eyelids, half-closed: 60 drugs.

Then a symptom of striking behavior, and new: his way of responding:
• PSYCHISM, Respond, monosyllables, by: 23 drugs.

Finally profuse night sweats:
• BREATHING, Abundant, profuse, at night: 95 drugs.

These three sections combined lead to 5 drugs: Mercurius., Phosphoric acid, Veratrum album, Thuja and Plumbum.

Mylène's fixed attitude, the loss of vital fluids (profuse sweating), the absence of any exuberance or fantasy designate Phosphoric acid.
The drug is confirmed by the answer to my question about a triggering cause or event: she is sad, a story with a girlfriend.
• PSYCHISM, Troubles following, Grief.
• PSYCHISM, Troubles following, Disappointed friendship.

Other possible headings:
• HEAD, Sweating, at night
• PSYCHISM, Response, Abrupt, dry.
• GENERAL, Mononucleosis.
• PSYCHISM, Silent grief, disappointed love.

PRESCRIPTION: PHOSPHORIC ACID 9 CH, 3 granules 3 times a day for 3 days.
Healing was rapid, fever and throat symptoms quickly subsided.

Some ideas about PHOSPHORIC ACID
Extracts from the Medical Subject "PRISMA" by Franz VERMEULEN
Do not want to talk ; short answers; always repeat the same depressing phrases: Life is useless; I don't want to live longer; everything is dark.
Indifferent to the things that interested him most (Kent).

Karl-Joseph Müller writes in substance: when you have the opposite of everything that makes Phosphorus: enthusiasm, expansion, interest and impetus towards beings and things, then you need Phosphoricum acidum : loss of interest, indifference, cessation of growth or destruction, slowness of ideation and introversion.

Hering's Encyclopedia:
- Consequences of worries, sorrow, pain, annoyance, homesickness, nostalgia, disappointed love.
- Throat - feeling of excoriation with burning of the soft palate.
- Throat - angina, soreness, scraping, stinging pain, worse when swallowing food.
The many symptoms of this medication corresponded well to my patient.

But obviously, it can only be placebo! : Shock:
Get out of your anti sites and go through personal experience. Try it on yourself instead of taking refuge in a simple supposition that ...
1 x
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré
User avatar
phil12
I posted 500 messages!
I posted 500 messages!
posts: 530
Registration: 05/10/09, 13:58
Location: Occitania
x 156

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by phil12 » 15/06/18, 12:25

Bonjour,

Some things to think about:

- a few years ago the psychosomatic disorders it was rubbish for the triumphant allopathy which was going to solve all the problems !!! (we see for example the results with antibiotics that start to get stuck : Cheesy:

- now when allopathy has failed it is psychosomatic (lime, levotirox, sensitive electros .....)

- scientific studies give a placebo success base of 30% therefore all allopathy, homeopathy, African grigri, healer of all kinds have a success of at least 30% it is great !!

- it means that by believing in something (including allopathy) 30% of people can heal themselves even more awesome : Idea: : Idea: : Idea:

- that if 30% of people heal themselves safely can earn billions

_ And that in 30% of cases allopathy releases us in the body of useless chemicals which are moreover which often have side effects

QED
1 x
Sustainable energy consulting for construction
http://www.philippeservices.net/
Janic
Econologue expert
Econologue expert
posts: 19224
Registration: 29/10/10, 13:27
Location: bourgogne
x 3491

Re: Homeopathy: proven effectiveness in India




by Janic » 15/06/18, 12:59

QED
absolutely! even if this 30% is not linked to a pacebo in many cases but to a placebo effect
who often have side effects
who ALWAYS have side effects as directed on VIDAL.
0 x
"We make science with facts, like making a house with stones: but an accumulation of facts is no more a science than a pile of stones is a house" Henri Poincaré

 


  • Similar topics
    Replies
    views
    Last message

Back to "Health and Prevention. Pollution, causes and effects of environmental risks "

Who is online ?

Users browsing this forum : No registered users and 248 guests