if it were to vote in the current parliament it would contradict the referendum ... we can not ask the current parliamentarians to deny their opinion to comply with the referendum
a logical way of not making a denial of democracy is a legislative election to renew the deputy ... and if the new parliament is to stay in Europe and the referendum can be forgotten
Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
- chatelot16
- Econologue expert
- posts: 6960
- Registration: 11/11/07, 17:33
- Location: Angouleme
- x 264
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
if it were to vote in the current parliament it would contradict the referendum ... we can not ask the current parliamentarians to deny their opinion to comply with the referendum
a logical way of not making a denial of democracy is a legislative election to renew the deputy ... and if the new parliament is to stay in Europe and the referendum can be forgotten
Yes, it demonstrates the swindle of representative democracy. The only major party that clearly proposes in France to leave Europe or at least organize a referendum is the FN. I have never voted FN and would never, yet I am for the exit of this Europe of finance.
0 x
- chatelot16
- Econologue expert
- posts: 6960
- Registration: 11/11/07, 17:33
- Location: Angouleme
- x 264
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
Democracy is very complicated ... but is it very reasonable to want to leave Europe and not want to elect the candidate who wants to leave europe?
I do not want to vote the pen ... and if the other candidates want to stay in Europe they may be right
going out of europe would be a huge job, who will do it? ... a referendum that decides to do something that nobody can do is it not a bit absurd?
we can understand that a small country wants to leave europe if there is too much problem, but France is not a small country ... if europe has problems the solution is not to go out but to find solutions ... England is not a small country either and has always been able to participate in the management of europe
what I want is not to leave europe but to better define their role: to take care of what is at its level and stop scribbling tons of paper to regulate details until the detail problem block the main
I do not want to vote the pen ... and if the other candidates want to stay in Europe they may be right
going out of europe would be a huge job, who will do it? ... a referendum that decides to do something that nobody can do is it not a bit absurd?
we can understand that a small country wants to leave europe if there is too much problem, but France is not a small country ... if europe has problems the solution is not to go out but to find solutions ... England is not a small country either and has always been able to participate in the management of europe
what I want is not to leave europe but to better define their role: to take care of what is at its level and stop scribbling tons of paper to regulate details until the detail problem block the main
0 x
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
Democracy is very complicated.
Because you confuse democracy and representative democracy. Democracy is for example a referendum of popular initiative, the representative democracy is elected a representative and then this representative does the opposite of what he promised, example Holland the enemy of finance
0 x
- chatelot16
- Econologue expert
- posts: 6960
- Registration: 11/11/07, 17:33
- Location: Angouleme
- x 264
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
You scare me ? What would happen if a multitude of refrendum made contradictory decisions? who would run?
good democracy remains to be invented, because I do not see a current democracy very effective
the loopholes of bad democracy are sometimes compensated by a great man who only has his head
the role of a democracy is not only to design the right leader, it should also be a way to eject the bad as quickly as possible
my idea would be deputed and president elected for life! as long as they are worthless to waste time on election ... but quick ejection when they are bad ... in the case of Holland it was visible from the beginning that he was unable to perform the function
the electoral lie is a calamity for the democracy: a canditat promises anything during the campaign and once elected it is indeboulonable
if the candidates knew he would be quickly ejected if he felt he would have no interest in making false promises
and that's where the popular initiative would be useful: to bring about a vote when an elect is too bad
good democracy remains to be invented, because I do not see a current democracy very effective
the loopholes of bad democracy are sometimes compensated by a great man who only has his head
the role of a democracy is not only to design the right leader, it should also be a way to eject the bad as quickly as possible
my idea would be deputed and president elected for life! as long as they are worthless to waste time on election ... but quick ejection when they are bad ... in the case of Holland it was visible from the beginning that he was unable to perform the function
the electoral lie is a calamity for the democracy: a canditat promises anything during the campaign and once elected it is indeboulonable
if the candidates knew he would be quickly ejected if he felt he would have no interest in making false promises
and that's where the popular initiative would be useful: to bring about a vote when an elect is too bad
0 x
- Philippe Schutt
- Econologue expert
- posts: 1611
- Registration: 25/12/05, 18:03
- Location: Alsace
- x 33
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
If elected officials promise and do what the people want, it's called populism, right? And it is denounced as shameful and contrary to the general interest. So I suppose a responsible government does the opposite of what the people want, but does it promise what it wants to be elected?
1 x
- Philippe Schutt
- Econologue expert
- posts: 1611
- Registration: 25/12/05, 18:03
- Location: Alsace
- x 33
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
Did67 wrote:edit: @Philippe Schutt
There is at least one point where the situation plays out: if you set up a factory in the EU, your product circulates without formality throughout the EU, which is still a big market.
that, it seems to me that it is for the European Economic Area. A country can be part of it without being part of the EU, for example Norway.
0 x
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
You scare me ? What would happen if a multitude of refrendum made contradictory decisions? who would run?
good democracy remains to be invented, because I do not see a current democracy very effective
We do not have to vote every week for contradictory decisions we had the 2005 referendum and the constitutional treaty that followed!
All political systems are not identical example:
Elections of proportional deputies with sometimes a bonus to the party arrived in 50 you deputies like in Greece
-Revocatory referendum of the president in Venezuela
-referendum of popular initiative.
-number of limited terms.
-bath of tar and feathers for cheaters ...
If you want to imagine crazy guards, the list is not closed.
0 x
-
- Moderator
- posts: 79120
- Registration: 10/02/03, 14:06
- Location: Greenhouse planet
- x 10973
Re: Victory Brexit: consequences for Europe?
raymon wrote:I am for the exit of this Europe of finance.
Like many of us ... no?
0 x
Do a image search or an text search - Netiquette of forum
Back to "Economy and finance, sustainability, growth, GDP, ecological tax systems"
Who is online ?
Users browsing this forum : No registered users and 149 guests